Whales and Us or What’s All the Fuss?


Charmaine Coimbra  

part 1 of 3

When whale watchers sight a nearby whale they either scream in excitement and capture the beast with cameras, or fire off a harpoon cannon and land an exploding harpoon into the surfacing cetacean then tow it in for harvesting.  

Two camps.  Two points of view.  One whale of a controversy.  

Whales and their human friends and foes will likely dominate environmental news up to and during the upcoming June 2010 International Whaling Commission (IWC) conference in Morocco.  

Neptune911 will attempt to consolidate and inform its readers about the current state of whales and whale hunting.  

The passion of the save the whales crowd ranges from  peaceful rallies like the recent rally  featured in the subsequent video, to the take no prisoners position of organizations like Sea Shepherd Conservation Society as broadcasted in the popular Animal Planet Whale Wars    production.

Whale hunters, either commercial or aboriginal, see whales as  a valuable commodity or creatures relevant to indigenous peoples’ sustainability.   

The whale meat industry even argues that by allowing more whale meat into the market that it may well help end human starvation, and that it is only the western nations interested in selling their beef products that challenge a “sustainable whale meat “ industry.  

Scientists, meanwhile warn of whale species extinction, highly toxic whale meat, and report that “…numerous scientific studies show that the makeup of cetacean brains (are) similar in structure to humans’.”  

As data continues to show that cetaceans harbor feelings and emotions, some ethicists assert that  hunting and/or capturing  cetaceans for arena entertainment is cruel.  This week, in fact, the Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society met in Helsinki, Finland.  It was there that Thomas White, director of the Center for Ethics and Business at Loyola Marymount University in California, told Reuters,  “Whaling is ethically unacceptable…. They have a sense of self that we used to think that only human beings have.”  

During a recent American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) conference, members agreed that whales and dolphins appear to possess cultural and cognitive processes. In other words, they are not without feelings and emotions.  

Ironically, science is one of the big issues concerning whale hunts.  Japan, along with Iceland and Norway, claim that many of the whales harvested are for scientific research and that their research has harvested more than just meat.  For instance, Japan states that the Antarctic minke whale is over abundant and hunting is essential to their natural balance.  Scientific studies disprove this claim.   

The anti-whaling community says that the IWC scientific study allowance for over-quota hunts is nothing more than a loophole.  

Who’s right?  What’s all the fuss?   

These are questions Neptune911 seeks to answer.  Your comments and additions are welcome as we continue exploring Whales and Us for the next several weeks.

Categories: Internatioanl Whaling Commission, Whales

Tags: , , ,

4 replies

  1. Good job!

  2. Very interesting, Charmaine. Check out


    While the BP Gulf of Mexico oil spill makes news because it is on the
    United States’ doorstep, spills commonly occur in other parts of the
    world with much less media attention.

    On June 8, 2010, which is World Oceans Day, the nonprofit conservation
    group SeaWeb will host a “Noon Newsmaker” news conference at the
    National Press Club in Washington, DC. The topic will be the state of
    the world’s oceans and the most challenging ocean conservation issues,
    including the Gulf of Mexico oil spill and what to expect in the way
    of long-term consequences of this disaster.

    Speakers will be conservationist Celine Costeau, Gulf marine
    biodiversity researcher Thomas Shirley, and LSU oceanography professor
    Robert Twilley (who heads the Coastal Emergency Response Assessment

    RSVP by June 4 to Anne Bolen, ; or contact Ken
    Goldman, 703-587-3226, .

    SeaWeb has also recently published a special edition of its Marine
    Science Review,which featured citations and abstracts about the
    impacts of oil spills.It can be downloaded from

    And you can follow a daily roundup of news about the oil spill in
    SeaWeb’s Ocean News portal


  1. Whale Hunt History And Today’s Whaler Death Ships « Neptune 911!
  2. chè tân cương

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: